Should You Buy or Lease Your Next Vehicle?

man considering financial impact of buying or leasing vehicle

Rising Prices, Rising Rates

New vehicle prices have skyrocketed these past few years, with the cost averaging well over $48,000 toward the end of 2023.1 These increased costs, coupled with rising interest rates, mean that buying a vehicle can take a significant bite out of your budget. If you are in the market for a new vehicle, you might be wondering if leasing it would save you money.

As a rule, if you plan on keeping a vehicle for a long period of time, it makes more sense to buy it. But if having the latest technology and safety features is important to you, leasing might be the best option, allowing you to drive a new vehicle every few years. To help you decide, you should also determine how each option fits into your lifestyle or budget. Here are some points to consider.


Total Cost When Buying

When you buy a vehicle, you usually finance a portion of the purchase price and pay it back over time with interest. When the loan term ends and the vehicle is paid for, you own it. You can keep it as long as you like, and any retained value (equity) is also yours to keep.

Total Cost When Leasing

When you lease a vehicle, you don't own it — the leasing company does — so you do not have any equity built up once the lease is over. At the end of the lease term, you can choose to either return the vehicle or buy it at its residual value, which is set forth in the lease. If you end up returning it early, the dealer may require you to pay a hefty fee. If you still need a vehicle at the end of the lease term, you'll need to start the leasing (or buying) process all over.

Share of new vehicle loans, by loan term
 percentage share of new vehicle loans by loan terms in number of months
Source: Experian, 2023

Monthly Payments

Payments When Buying

If you finance all or part of your new vehicle purchase, you will have a monthly payment that will vary based on the amount you finance, the interest rate, and the loan term. When comparing loans, it's important to look at the total amount of money you will end up paying over the life of the loan. While a longer loan term may give you a more affordable monthly payment, you will end up paying more money over the loan term.

Payments When Leasing

In general, monthly lease payments are usually lower than monthly loan payments since you are mainly paying for the vehicle's depreciation during the lease term as opposed to the purchase price. This means that leasing may allow you to drive a more expensive vehicle than what you could otherwise afford.


Mileage Considerations When Buying

How much do you plan on driving? When you buy a vehicle, you can drive it as many miles as you want. However, a vehicle with higher mileage may be worth less if you plan to trade it in or sell it at some point down the road.

Mileage Considerations When Leasing

Vehicle leases come with up-front mileage limits, typically ranging from 12,000 to 15,000 miles per year. If you exceed these limits, you can end up incurring costly penalties in the form of excess mileage charges.

Maintenance Costs

Maintenance Costs When Buying

When you sell your vehicle, condition matters, so you may receive less if it hasn't been well maintained. As your vehicle ages, repair bills may be greater, something you typically won't encounter if you lease.

Maintenance Costs When Leasing

Generally, you will have to service a leased vehicle according to the manufacturer's recommendations. In addition, you'll need to return your vehicle with normal wear and tear (according to the leasing company's definition). Anything above normal wear and tear may result in excess charges.

Up-Front Costs

Up-Front Costs When Buying

When you buy a vehicle, the up-front costs you incur may include the cash price or a down payment for the vehicle, taxes, title, and other fees.

Up-Front Costs When Leasing

The up-front costs associated with leasing a vehicle may include an acquisition fee, down payment, security deposit, first month's payment, taxes, title, and other fees.

Additional Buying Vs. Leasing Tips

Keep the following tips in mind when determining whether or not to buy or lease a vehicle:
  • Shop wisely. Make sure you read the fine print and fully understand all terms or conditions.
  • Negotiate. To get the best deal, be prepared to negotiate the price of the vehicle and the terms of any loan/lease offer.
  • Run the numbers. Calculate both the short-term and long-term costs associated with each option.
  • Consider tax implications. This is especially important if you use your vehicle for business and/or have an electric vehicle.

1) Kelley Blue Book, 2024

  • To learn more about our firm, click here to download the SouthState Advisory Brochure or click here to download the SouthState Advisory Form CRS.

    SouthState Advisory, a wholly owned subsidiary of SouthState Bank, N.A. also does business under the name SouthState Retirement Plan Services. Investments offered are not deposits of this institution and therefore are not insured or guaranteed by the FDIC or any government agency. We do not provide, and you should not construe this material as legal, tax or accounting advice. Nor should you construe this material as individual investment advice, because such advice is dependent on your specific investment objectives, financial situation, or particular needs The content of the SouthState Retirement Plan Services website is not directed toward or intended for individuals outside of the U.S. Click here for additional regulatory disclosures. PRIVACY POLICY

Secure Log In

Close login menu
Login Error

Your username is valid but has a problem. Please call customer support

Our website uses cookies to ensure your online experience is as informative and relevant as possible. Please review our Privacy Policy to learn more about the information we collect.